Table of contents

What if you wake up one day to find your hard-earned savings drained or loans taken out in your name—scenarios that have become all too common with identity theft on the rise? It is a scary scenario, isn’t it? In 2023 alone, the FTC received over 1 million identity theft reports, with losses exceeding a staggering $10.3 billion. For many, the damage to finances and credit is devastating, and it often takes years to recover.

But here’s the real question: how can you protect your credit and financial health when cybercriminals are constantly evolving their tactics? Credit monitoring services are your first line of defense, alerting you to unauthorized activities before they spiral out of control. However, not all services are equal—some offer only partial coverage, leaving you exposed to fraud even when you think you're protected.

Ready to find the best place to monitor your credit score and safeguard your future? Let’s dive into the blog and explore solutions.

What To Look For in a Credit Monitoring Service?

Although the majority of credit monitoring services have a similar appearance, they differ and have subtleties that affect the degree of protection they offer. We consider the following five factors while evaluating the top credit monitoring services for 2024:

  1. Monitoring credit through three bureaus. Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion are the three main credit bureaus, and they each gather distinct credit data. Without three-bureau credit monitoring, you might not be able to see warning signs of identity theft. 

  1. Alerts that are accurate and timely. Near real-time, precise, and comprehensive alerts are required. All questionable behavior should be covered by notifications, including significant alterations, errors, and inconsistencies in your credit data. We choose services that provide fraud alert speed data and support it with independent testing. 

  1. The cost. The monthly cost of most paid credit monitoring services can well surpass $20. Although there are free options, their features and protection are typically restricted. 

  1. Use FICO® or VantageScore® as the credit scoring model. When determining credit scores, each scoring model employs a particular set of weights and values. For instance, VantageScore® is more concerned with credit mix, whereas FICO® is more concerned with credit balance. 

  1. Combined fraud protection. To protect yourself from fraud and identity theft, you need more than just credit monitoring. We search for services that offer easily accessible help and recovery alternatives, as well as proactive antivirus and anti-phishing capabilities. 

Secure your credit and personal information with real-time alerts and advanced fraud protection. Learn how Shepherd Outsourcing can help you safeguard your financial future. 

The 8 Best Paid and Free Credit Monitoring Services (2024)

The top credit monitoring services include bank account monitoring, three-bureau credit monitoring, and quick and accurate fraud warnings. They also offer proactive identity theft protection and easily available recovery assistance in the event that you are a victim.

Some, but not all, of these functions were well-executed by the majority of credit monitoring companies. 

We've produced a list of the top eight credit monitoring services and credit score applications, both free and premium, to help you pick the right one for you.

Note: Businesses frequently alter plans, costs, and features on a regular basis. Although we make every effort to present the most recent information, data is only valid as of the publication date.

  1. Shepherd Outsourcing 

Why we picked it: Shepherd Outsourcing has earned a reputation as a reliable and transparent provider of credit monitoring and debt relief services. Known for its personalized approach to credit repair and debt management, it offers robust protection through three-bureau credit monitoring, real-time alerts, and expert support. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Shepherd Outsourcing is a trusted name for those seeking to manage their financial recovery.

Each of Shepherd Outsourcing’s credit monitoring plans comes with three-bureau credit monitoring, fraud alerts, and identity theft protection services. They offer a tailored solution based on individual financial situations, making it a standout choice for those who want personalized, hands-on assistance.

Shepherd Outsourcing Pros

  • Comprehensive Three-Bureau Credit Monitoring: Shepherd Outsourcing monitors all three major credit bureaus—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion—ensuring you have a complete picture of your credit status.
  • Real-Time Alerts: Get immediate notifications for any changes to your credit, from new accounts to inquiries, so you can take action quickly.
  • Personalized Support: Shepherd Outsourcing provides expert customer service with tailored solutions, ensuring you receive the help you need when navigating your financial recovery.
  • Fraud Protection: Includes identity theft protection and fraud recovery assistance, giving you peace of mind if your information is compromised.
  • Affordable Pricing: Shepherd Outsourcing’s plans are cost-effective, offering valuable protection at a competitive price without high upfront costs.

Shepherd Outsourcing cons

  • No Free Plan: Shepherd Outsourcing focuses on delivering premium, comprehensive services tailored to meet the diverse needs of its clients. While it doesn’t offer a free version, this ensures all users receive robust support and high-quality solutions, rather than a limited experience. m
  • Limited Additional Features: While the service excels in credit monitoring and fraud protection, it does not offer the same wide array of financial tools (like financial planning or account monitoring) available with some other providers.

Shepherd Outsourcing offers one straightforward plan that covers three-bureau credit monitoring, real-time alerts, identity theft protection, and access to expert support. Their Comprehensive Plan is affordable and designed to meet the needs of individuals who want complete coverage without unnecessary extras.

  1. Identity Guard

Why we picked it: With over 20 years of experience in identity theft protection, Identity Guard has established itself as a leader in the industry. Over that time, it has helped more than 47 million customers and resolved over 140,000 fraud cases.

Identity Guard provides three-bureau credit monitoring in two of its three plans, along with monthly VantageScore® credit scores, Dark Web scanning, bank account monitoring, device protection, and up to $1 million in identity theft insurance. Their plans are designed to keep you informed and protected against both credit issues and identity theft.

Identity Guard pros

  • Strong Identity Theft Protection: Identity Guard provides a robust level of identity theft protection, comparable to services like Aura, ensuring your personal information is safeguarded.
  • Financial Account Monitoring: It includes considerable monitoring of bank and investment accounts, as well as scanning the Dark Web for your personal data.
  • 60-Day Money-Back Guarantee: If you opt for an annual plan, you’ll have peace of mind with a 60-day money-back guarantee.
  • White Glove Fraud Resolution: Available on the Ultra plan, this premium service offers personalized support to help resolve fraud cases quickly.

Identity Guard cons

  • No Credit Monitoring on the Value Plan: The most basic plan doesn’t include credit monitoring, which may not be ideal for those looking for comprehensive coverage.
  • Limited Digital Security Features: While Identity Guard offers solid identity and credit protection, it lacks more extensive digital security tools found with other providers.
  • White Glove Fraud Support Only on the Ultra Plan: The premium fraud resolution service is only available on the higher-tier Ultra plan, which may not be accessible to everyone.

Best plan & average cost: Identity Guard Ultra for $25/month

Identity Guard's Ultra plan offers premium credit protection, including three-bureau credit monitoring, monthly credit scores, and Experian CreditLock. Additionally, it covers bank accounts, investment accounts, and public records monitoring, making it a comprehensive option for those seeking thorough protection.

Get Identity Guard’s Ultra Plan for $25/month and enjoy premium protection for your credit and identity, along with advanced monitoring tools to help you stay ahead of any potential fraud.

  1. Experian IdentityWorks

Why we picked it: As a service owned and operated by Experian, one of the three major credit bureaus, IdentityWorks is backed by the authority and reliability of a trusted name in the credit industry. With over 100 years of experience, Experian offers robust credit monitoring services that can help protect your financial future.

IdentityWorks offers a Basic plan that provides free Experian credit report monitoring and FICO® score tracking. For those seeking more comprehensive coverage, the Premium plan includes three-bureau credit monitoring, an Experian CreditLock, daily FICO® scores, and identity alerts.

Experian IdentityWorks pros

  • Daily FICO® Scores: Unlike most other services that offer VantageScore®, IdentityWorks provides daily FICO® scores, which lenders widely use to evaluate creditworthiness.
  • Free Credit Monitoring Service: The Basic plan is free and provides essential Experian credit monitoring, making it a good starting point for individuals who want to keep an eye on their credit without any upfront costs.
  • 7-Day Free Trial: You can try out the Premium plan risk-free for 7 days, giving you the opportunity to test out all the features before committing.
  • Solid Identity Theft Protection: The Premium plan offers identity theft alerts and insurance, along with three-bureau monitoring for more comprehensive protection.

Experian IdentityWorks cons

  • No Digital Security Features: Despite its robust credit monitoring and identity theft protection, there are no digital security tools (like antivirus or VPN services) included in any of the plans.
  • Limited Features on Free Plan: The free Basic plan only provides basic monitoring of Experian credit reports, which may not be sufficient for those seeking more thorough protection.
  • Customer Service Availability: Customer service is available, but only during limited hours, which may be inconvenient for some users.
  • Potential Legal Trade-Off: By using services from Experian or other bureaus, you might waive your right to join a class action lawsuit if your data is breached.

Best plan & average cost: IdentityWorks Premium for $24.99/month

The Premium plan is the most comprehensive option, offering three-bureau credit monitoring, daily FICO® scores, Experian CreditLock, identity theft alerts, and insurance coverage, all for $24.99/month.

Get started with IdentityWorks Premium for $24.99/month, and enjoy detailed credit monitoring, daily FICO® scores, and identity theft protection to keep your finances secure.

  1. CreditWise by Capital One

Why we picked it: CreditWise, administered by Capital One, offers users a simple and accessible way to monitor their financial health without any cost. This service allows you to track your credit with ease, providing a clear picture of how your financial decisions affect your credit score.

CreditWise offers two-bureau credit monitoring with TransUnion and Experian, a VantageScore® credit report tracker, and credit alerts to keep you informed about any changes. Users can also request their credit reports at any time and gain insights into their credit status with a free service.

CreditWise pros

  • Free Credit Monitoring: CreditWise is completely free, offering access to TransUnion VantageScore® credit tracking without any hidden fees.
  • Easy Sign-Up: Signing up for CreditWise is quick and straightforward, and it’s available to anyone with a valid Social Security number (SSN).
  • Credit Simulator: The service includes a credit simulator, which allows users to test how certain financial actions may impact their credit score, giving them the ability to make informed decisions.
  • Credit Report Access: You can request your credit reports 24/7, offering full transparency and understanding of your credit history.

CreditWise cons

  • Limited Credit Monitoring: Credit monitoring is limited to only two bureaus—TransUnion and Experian—meaning you won’t get a complete picture from all three major credit bureaus.
  • No Identity Protection Features: CreditWise lacks digital security tools or identity theft protection, leaving users without any proactive defense against fraud or theft.
  • No Dark Web Protection: While the service offers a credit report tracker and alerts, it doesn’t include advanced protections such as Dark Web scanning for stolen data.
  • Basic Coverage: The free service is limited in terms of coverage, and there are no premium features or added benefits for users who need more extensive protection.

Best plan & average cost: CreditWise (Free)

CreditWise offers only one free plan that includes two-bureau credit monitoring, credit score tracking, and access to a credit report tracker. It’s a solid option for those who want basic credit monitoring at no cost.

Get started with CreditWise for free and gain easy access to credit score tracking and credit report monitoring, all with no cost involved.

  1. LifeLock

Why we picked it: LifeLock has been a trusted name in identity theft protection and credit monitoring for nearly 20 years. After being acquired by Symantec in 2017, LifeLock added Norton’s digital security tools to some of its packages, providing an even more comprehensive protection service.

LifeLock offers a range of plans, with the Standard plan featuring one-bureau credit monitoring and the Ultimate plans providing three-bureau monitoring, unlimited VantageScore® updates, a TransUnion credit file lock, and up to $3 million in identity theft insurance. Additionally, LifeLock includes substantial identity and financial account monitoring for added protection.

LifeLock pros

  • Extensive Identity Theft Monitoring: LifeLock provides comprehensive monitoring and alerts, helping you stay informed of any suspicious activity related to your identity.
  • 24/7 Live Member Support: LifeLock offers round-the-clock customer support, with priority support available for Ultimate plan members.
  • Three-Bureau Credit Monitoring (Ultimate Plans): The Ultimate plans include three-bureau credit monitoring, giving you a full view of your credit across all three major bureaus.
  • Optional Digital Security: For an additional fee, LifeLock includes Norton 360 digital security tools, adding extra layers of protection against online threats.

LifeLock cons

  • Confusing Plan Options: LifeLock’s plans can be difficult to navigate, making it challenging to determine which features are included at each level.
  • Limited Coverage on Standard Plans: The Standard plan offers only one-bureau credit monitoring and basic identity monitoring, leaving users without full coverage for more comprehensive protection.
  • High Renewal Rates: While LifeLock offers a reasonable initial price, be aware that renewal rates can increase significantly—up to 40%—after the first year.
  • No Free Plan: LifeLock does not offer a free tier, which may deter those looking for basic monitoring without committing to a paid plan.

Best plan & average cost: LifeLock Ultimate Plus for $19.99/month

LifeLock’s Ultimate Plus plan includes three-bureau credit monitoring, unlimited access to your credit score, identity monitoring with alerts, and up to $3 million in identity theft insurance. However, be aware of the significant price increase after the first year of service.

Get LifeLock Ultimate Plus for $19.99/month and enjoy comprehensive three-bureau credit monitoring, identity theft protection, and exclusive Norton 360 digital security tools. Just be prepared for a significant price increase after your first year.

  1. MyFICO®

Why we picked it: MyFICO, developed by the creators of FICO® credit scores, makes it easy for users to monitor their credit health with a focus on the FICO® scores most commonly used by lenders. With its extensive range of tools and resources, MyFICO is ideal for those who want to dive deep into their credit status and receive valuable financial insights.

MyFICO offers three plans, including a free option that provides FICO® score tracking, but only the paid plans give access to three-bureau credit monitoring, identity monitoring, mortgage and auto loan interest rate updates, and up to $1 million in identity theft insurance.

MyFICO Pros

  • Free Plan Available: MyFICO’s free plan allows users to track their FICO® credit score, which is one of the most widely used credit scores by lenders.
  • FICO® Score Focus: As the company that created FICO® scores, MyFICO provides access to the most accurate representation of your credit score, giving users an edge when it comes to understanding their financial standing.
  • Financial Resources: Paid plans come with detailed financial tools and resources designed to help you improve your credit and better manage your finances.
  • Comprehensive Support: Restoration support is available on the paid plans, providing assistance in the event of fraud or identity theft.

MyFICO cons

  • No Digital Security Features: While MyFICO excels at credit monitoring, it lacks comprehensive digital security tools like anti-virus software or identity theft protection found in other services.
  • Expensive Paid Plans: MyFICO’s paid plans are among the priciest on the market, with the Premier plan costing $39.95/month—more than many competing services offering similar features.
  • Limited Identity Theft Protection: Even with its premium plans, MyFICO’s identity theft protection features are relatively limited compared to other services in the same price range.
  • FICO® Scores Are Free Elsewhere: FICO® scores can be accessed for free from many banks and credit card issuers, so MyFICO's paid services may not justify the cost for some users.

Best plan & average cost: MyFICO Premier for $39.95/month

The Premier plan provides comprehensive three-bureau credit monitoring, monthly FICO® score updates, and basic identity monitoring. However, it comes at a high price compared to other services that offer similar features for less.

  1. Credit Karma

Why we picked it: Credit Karma, a product of Intuit, offers a free credit and financial health monitoring service that is easily accessible to anyone looking to keep tabs on their credit. The service provides credit monitoring for TransUnion and Equifax credit reports, unlimited access to VantageScore® credit scores, and real-time credit alerts—all at no cost to you.

What you should know about Credit Karma’s “free” services: Credit Karma’s services are free, but the company generates revenue by promoting credit cards, loans, and other financial products. They earn a commission when users sign up for these products through the platform. Additionally, Credit Karma has faced some controversies, including a $3 million fine from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for misleading advertising of "pre-approved" credit offers and a security breach that exposed users' personal finance data.

Credit Karma pros

  • Free Credit Monitoring: Credit Karma offers access to TransUnion and Equifax credit reports, as well as unlimited VantageScore® credit scores, completely free.
  • Debt Relief Support: The platform provides resources and guidance for users looking for help with managing or relieving debt.
  • Credit Profile: Users receive a credit profile that allows them to track their credit scores over time and access personalized recommendations for improving their financial health.

Credit Karma cons

  • No Digital Security Tools: Unlike many other credit monitoring services, Credit Karma does not offer digital security features, like anti-virus or identity theft protection.
  • Limited to Two Bureaus: Credit Karma only monitors credit from TransUnion and Equifax, which leaves out Experian.
  • No Identity Monitoring: The service does not include monitoring for identity theft or fraud, leaving users unprotected in this area.
  • Revenue from Product Recommendations: The free service relies on promoting credit cards and loans, which might feel like a hidden agenda for users who just want to monitor their credit without being pitched products.
  • Privacy Concerns: The company has faced fines and scrutiny over past data security issues, including a security glitch that exposed users' personal data to others.

Best plan & average cost: Credit Karma Free Plan

Credit Karma offers a single plan that is completely free, making it an attractive option for those who just need basic credit monitoring.

  1. Credit Sesame

Why we picked it: Credit Sesame offers users free access to credit monitoring with an emphasis on understanding and improving your credit score. Users can monitor their VantageScore® credit scores and credit reports from TransUnion, with free tools to help manage their financial health.

Credit Sesame pros

  • Free Credit Monitoring: The service provides free credit monitoring and access to your VantageScore® credit score, making it easy for users to track their credit without any cost.
  • Educational Tools: Credit Sesame includes free credit tips, guides, and action plans to help users better understand their credit scores and make informed financial decisions.
  • Simple and Easy to Use: The free plan offers straightforward access to credit reports and scores, making it easy for beginners to understand and monitor their credit.

Credit Sesame cons

  • Limited to One Bureau: Unlike other services, Credit Sesame only monitors credit from TransUnion, which may not give you a full picture of your credit health.
  • No Digital Security or Identity Protection: Credit Sesame offers no digital security tools or identity theft protection, so it doesn't safeguard against fraud or data breaches.
  • Unclear Premium Plans: The details around the premium plans and what they offer in terms of coverage and protection are vague, making it difficult to assess whether they are worth upgrading to.

Best plan & average cost: Credit Sesame Free Plan

Credit Sesame offers a free basic plan, which includes VantageScore® credit score tracking, credit report summaries, and helpful financial tips.

While each credit monitoring service on this list has its strengths, Shepherd Outsourcing rises above the competition with its tailored solutions, three-bureau credit monitoring, and real-time fraud alerts. Unlike free plans that often compromise on coverage, Shepherd’s focus on premium, hands-on support ensures you receive reliable protection and expert assistance when you need it most.

Do You Really Need To Pay For a Credit Monitoring Service?

It's true that tracking your credit file and scores can be done mostly for free. For instance, every American is entitled to access a free credit report from all three major bureaus—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion—once per year at AnnualCreditReport.com.

Additionally, some financial institutions, including banks and credit card providers, offer free credit monitoring services as an incentive for signing up. If a company or service you use experiences a data breach, they may offer free credit monitoring through specialized services like Kroll or IDX.

But before you rely entirely on these free services, it's important to consider the downsides of monitoring your own credit or using basic, free tools:

  1. Limited Scope

Free credit monitoring services almost never provide full identity theft protection, insurance, or three-bureau credit monitoring. Many only monitor one or two credit bureaus, leaving you exposed if fraud or errors are reported to a different bureau.

Example: If fraud occurs at TransUnion and you’re only monitoring Equifax, you might not get an alert until much later, when the damage is already done.

  1. Reliability Concerns

Most free services only notify you of major credit changes like new accounts or credit inquiries, missing many of the smaller red flags that could point to identity theft earlier on.

Example: A thief could use your personal information to apply for a small loan, which might not trigger an alert if the free tool only monitors for large transactions or new credit lines.

  1. Slow Alerts

Fraud alerts from free services are often delayed, arriving well after an event has occurred. In some cases, by the time you’re alerted to potential fraud, it’s too late to take action and prevent significant damage.

Example: By the time you’re notified about a credit inquiry or a new account opened in your name, the fraud may have already spread to other areas of your life.

  1. Lack of Customer Support

Many free services offer minimal support when it comes to handling fraud cases, and the help that is provided may not be available during off-hours or when you need it most. For people facing active fraud or identity theft, this can be incredibly frustrating and overwhelming.

Example: If you notice a fraudulent charge and need to take action immediately, free services often don’t provide the round-the-clock support that a dedicated identity theft protection service can offer.

The Bottom Line: Free Monitoring Isn’t Enough

While free credit monitoring tools are accessible and helpful for basic tracking, they come with significant limitations. The average person likely won't have the time or expertise to monitor credit across all three bureaus and follow up with all the necessary checks to prevent identity theft or fraud.

Even if you’re using a free tool, you’ll probably still need to monitor your credit reports from other bureaus that aren’t covered in your plan. Crucially, free services don’t offer protection or remedies for identity theft, meaning that if your data is compromised, you’ll have no control over how it’s used or what happens next.

The risks are high—hackers, scammers, and identity thieves don’t wait for permission to strike, and often, by the time you're alerted, the damage is already done. This is why opting for comprehensive, paid credit monitoring with robust protection is usually a far more effective solution. When it comes to safeguarding your financial health and personal data, relying on free services alone is often a gamble you can't afford to take.

Don’t wait for a data breach to happen—monitor your credit with Shepherd Outsourcing’s expert services today. Sign up for a risk-free trial and experience premium protection.